
Sea Crest Beach Resort
Best for families and guests who want direct, private beach access and multiple pools and on-site casual dining options.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Sea Crest Beach Resort is a family-friendly mainland beachfront resort on Old Silver Beach in North Falmouth; readers who want direct private beach access, pools, and kid-focused facilities should read this. Edgar Hotel Martha's Vineyard, an Ascend Collection Hotel is a branded island hotel in central Edgartown; read it if you want a compact, recognized hotel on Martha’s Vineyard with easy access to town and island attractions.
Updated

Best for families and guests who want direct, private beach access and multiple pools and on-site casual dining options.

Best for travelers who want a recognizable, centrally located hotel on Martha’s Vineyard with easy access to Edgartown and island ferries.
When Sea Crest Beach Resort wins: choose Sea Crest when you want an oceanfront resort with private beach access, multiple on-site dining options and pools, family amenities (arcade, children’s pool) and larger event/wedding space.
When Edgar Hotel Martha's Vineyard wins: pick Edgar Hotel for a compact, branded hotel located in Edgartown for exploring Martha’s Vineyard, short drives to beaches and island attractions, and the convenience of a single on-site American restaurant and free parking.
Bottom line: Sea Crest is the better fit for full-service, beachfront resort stays and family trips on the Cape; Edgar suits travelers whose priority is staying on Martha’s Vineyard in a well-known, walkable Edgartown location.
| Category | Sea Crest Beach Resort | Edgar Hotel Martha's Vineyard, an Ascend Collection Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Larger, family-oriented beachfront resort with resort amenities and event spaces. | Smaller, branded island hotel in town with straightforward rooms and local access. |
| Location | Directly on Old Silver Beach, North Falmouth (private beach access). | In central Edgartown — short drive/walk to beaches and town sites. |
| Size / rooms | About 253 rooms listed across the property (multiple room types and suites). | 41 guestrooms (listing). |
| Ages / audience | All ages — family-friendly (children’s pool, arcade, kids-stay-free policy). | All ages — not adults-only; family and general travelers welcome. |
| Pools | Indoor pool (year-round), seasonal outdoor pool, and a children's pool. | Not published |
| Beach access | Private direct access to Old Silver Beach with towels, loungers, umbrellas. | Beaches are nearby (Edgartown Beach, Lighthouse Beach, etc.), but the hotel is not listed as beachfront. |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues: The Lantern Room (full-service), The Hatch (poolside), Buzzards Bay Pizza Co., Captain Scoops, Old Silver Provisions. | Town Bar and Grill (American cuisine) plus room service; one on-site restaurant and a bar/lounge. |
| Spa / wellness | Spa services reported via a partnership (Bellezza Salon Medspa) and on-site fitness center (sources vary). | Not published |
| Event & wedding space | Extensive: multiple ballrooms and outdoor ceremony options; over 30,000 sq ft of event space and capacity for large weddings. | Smaller property — event/wedding capacity not listed in supplier facts. |
| Parking & transport | Free self-parking on site; ferry access to Martha’s Vineyard is possible as a day trip. | Free self-parking; closest island airport recommended is Vineyard Haven (MVY). |
Sea Crest sits directly on Old Silver Beach in North Falmouth, giving immediate access to sand and water.
Choose Sea Crest if you prioritize walking out to a private beach and Cape Cod coastal access.
Edgar Hotel sits in central Edgartown on Martha’s Vineyard, close to town services and island beaches.
Choose Edgar if you want to stay on Martha’s Vineyard inside easy reach of Edgartown’s town center and island attractions.
Sea Crest offers a mix of oceanfront rooms, sun-deck rooms, and larger suites and family studios.
Sea Crest provides more room variety and dedicated family/suite options with ocean views.
Edgar offers 41 guestrooms in a compact, town-focused property with standard in-room amenities.
Edgar suits travelers who want comfortable, straightforward rooms in town rather than beachfront suite options.
Sea Crest has a cluster of on-site dining choices that cover full meals and poolside/snack options.
Sea Crest is better if you want multiple, on-site casual and full-service dining choices without leaving property.
Edgar has one featured on-site restaurant and bar plus room service as an option.
Edgar is good when you plan to eat out in Edgartown or want a single on-site American restaurant.
Sea Crest’s signature amenity is direct access to Old Silver Beach plus multiple resort pools.
Sea Crest’s pools and private beach make it a clear choice for swimmers and beach-focused families.
Edgar’s main appeal is being on Martha’s Vineyard with easy access to island beaches and boat tours.
Edgar is better if your priority is staying on Martha’s Vineyard and using the island as your base to reach beaches and tours.
Sea Crest offers a fitness center and reported spa services via a local partnership, plus casual evening dining and bars.
Sea Crest supports active and relaxed wellness options plus family-friendly evening dining and bars.
Edgar provides basic guest amenities and quick access to Edgartown’s nightlife and dining scene.
Edgar is useful if you want to step into Edgartown for nightlife and island dining rather than a resort’s on-site scene.

Sea Crest — private direct access to Old Silver Beach with towels, loungers and umbrellas.

Edgar Hotel — a branded hotel in central Edgartown with easy access to island beaches and town.

Sea Crest — children’s pool, arcade/game room and family-friendly dining make it easier for kids.

Edgar Hotel — smaller property and on-site Town Bar and Grill put you close to Edgartown’s shops and services.
Sea Crest — it has direct private beach access, a children’s pool, poolside dining and an arcade, all aimed at families.
Pick Edgar Hotel if you want to be on Martha’s Vineyard in Edgartown with short walks to town and easy island transport options.
No — neither property is described as all-inclusive; Sea Crest’s breakfast and some dining come at an extra charge and Edgar lists on-site restaurant and room service options.
No — supplier facts list nearby beaches and distances, but the Edgar Hotel is not described as directly beachfront.
Explore how Sea Crest Beach Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·