
Sea Crest Beach Resort
Best for families and beach-first Cape Cod stays with multiple pools, kid-friendly dining, and a private stretch of Old Silver Beach.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Sea Crest Beach Resort is a family-friendly beachfront resort on Old Silver Beach in North Falmouth, best for travelers who want a classic Cape Cod beach and lots of on-site activities. Faraway Martha's Vineyard is an upscale boutique hotel in central Edgartown, best for travelers who want a walkable island base for restaurants, galleries, and short trips to nearby beaches.
Updated

Best for families and beach-first Cape Cod stays with multiple pools, kid-friendly dining, and a private stretch of Old Silver Beach.

Best for an upscale, walkable Martha’s Vineyard stay in Edgartown with boutique rooms and easy access to the town and lighthouse.
When Sea Crest Beach Resort wins: choose Sea Crest if you want direct private beach access, a resort layout with multiple pools (indoor, seasonal outdoor, and a children's pool), and family-focused amenities like an arcade, poolside dining, and activity options.
When Faraway Martha's Vineyard wins: pick Faraway if you prefer a smaller, boutique island hotel in downtown Edgartown with short walks to the Edgartown Lighthouse and town shops and restaurants; it suits travelers wanting an island-base experience rather than a resort property.
Bottom line: Sea Crest is a larger, activity-filled beachfront resort aimed at families and group events; Faraway is a compact, upscale Edgartown hotel for guests prioritizing town access and an island setting.
| Category | Sea Crest Beach Resort | Faraway Martha's Vineyard |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Large, family-oriented beachfront resort with many on-site activities and event spaces. | Upscale boutique hotel in the heart of Edgartown with a more intimate, town-hotel feel. |
| Location | Directly on Old Silver Beach in North Falmouth with private beach access. | Centrally located in Edgartown; about a 0.5–0.6 km walk to Edgartown Lighthouse and Lighthouse Beach. |
| Size (rooms) | About 253 guest rooms (multiple room types and suites reported). | 58 guestrooms noted in the supplier listing. |
| Ages / audience | All ages — family-focused with children's pool, arcade, and kids-stay-free policy. | All ages — not adults-only; boutique hotel welcoming a range of guests. |
| Pools | Indoor pool (year-round), seasonal outdoor pool, plus a separate children's pool. | One outdoor seasonal pool (listed); pool access hours and seasonality noted. |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site restaurants and casual outlets (The Lantern Room, The Hatch, Buzzards Bay Pizza Co., Captain Scoops, Old Silver Provisions) and pool/beach bars. | Two on-site restaurants and multiple bars/lounges; The Newes from America among the options. |
| Spa / wellness | Spa services have been reported via a partnership (Bellezza) and the property lists fitness facilities; some listings vary on an on-site spa. | Not published |
| Known for | Private access to Old Silver Beach, large event/wedding spaces, family programming. | Central Edgartown location within easy walking distance of the lighthouse and town attractions. |
| Parking | Free self-parking on site (some third-party listings mention fees for extra vehicles). | Parking available but limited spaces noted in the supplier listing. |
| Accessibility & services | 24-hour front desk, concierge, on-site meeting/event space, wheelchair-accessible options reported. | 24-hour front desk, concierge, wheelchair-accessible paths and services; free WiFi and wired internet noted. |
Sea Crest sits directly on Old Silver Beach in North Falmouth, a short walk to the sand and about seven miles from Falmouth's Main Street.
A true Cape Cod beachfront setting — choose this for sand-first beach days and easy mainland day trips.
Faraway is centrally located in Edgartown, within a short walk of Edgartown Lighthouse and town shops and restaurants.
Pick Faraway if you want a walkable island base where town life is your main nearby attraction.
Sea Crest offers a range of room types from oceanfront rooms to family suites and studio suites with fireplaces.
Bigger property with family-friendly room variety and direct beach-facing options.
Faraway's guestroom list shows many suite configurations and a compact inventory that reads like a boutique inn.
Choose Faraway for boutique-style suites and a smaller, quieter room inventory in Edgartown.
Sea Crest centers dining around family and poolside options plus a year-round restaurant with ocean views.
A wide variety of casual and full-service dining ideal for families and pool/beach days.
Faraway lists two restaurants and multiple bars/lounges that fit an upscale island-hotel profile.
Faraway is a good base for boutique dining on-site and a short walk to Edgartown’s restaurants.
Sea Crest combines an indoor pool, a seasonal outdoor pool, and a children's pool with immediate beach access.
Sea Crest is designed around pool and beach days for families and groups.
Faraway offers an outdoor pool and places greater emphasis on town and island access than large beach facilities.
Faraway suits guests who want a hotel pool and prefer nearby island beaches and marine activities.
Sea Crest lists fitness facilities and multiple third-party references to spa services; nightlife is mostly family-focused dining and bars.
Sea Crest focuses on fitness, family entertainment, and occasional spa services rather than nightlife.
Faraway emphasizes boutique hotel services, concierge, and easy access to Edgartown's evening dining and waterfront bars.
Faraway suits guests who want concierge-arranged island activities and to walk into Edgartown for nights out.

Sea Crest — children’s pool, arcade, poolside casual dining, and a kids-stay-free policy make it the easier family pick.

Sea Crest — direct private access to Old Silver Beach and on-site beach services put you on the sand quickly.

Faraway — a smaller boutique property in walking distance of Edgartown’s shops, galleries, and lighthouse.

Faraway — fewer rooms and central location make it convenient for island activities and walking to restaurants.
Sea Crest is better for families: it lists a children's pool, an arcade/game room, family-oriented dining, and a kids-stay-free policy.
Yes — Faraway is centrally located in Edgartown with several landmarks and beaches within a short walk (about 0.2–0.6 km to nearby points).
Yes — Sea Crest provides private access to Old Silver Beach with seasonal chair and umbrella service and beach towels included with the resort fee.
No — Faraway is not published as adults-only; the supplier listing shows amenities and room types for general guests.
Explore how Sea Crest Beach Resort stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·